Sunday, November 10, 2013
American Prisons, A Bandaid Over A Broken System
It is beyond contention that the growth of poverty, crime, violence and incarceration rates within predominantly black and latino inner city communities is perpetuated by biased drug laws, a negatively incentivized police force, and the prison industrial complex. These three forces combined are hugely responsible for the spike in prison construction and incarceration rates, followed by the systematic disenfranchisement of low class American citizens, specifically black and brown men. For those unaware of the corruption and prejudice surrounding these issues, the illusion of safety that the police and prison industry go to great lengths to maintain is graciously embraced. As I see it, this outlook (one taken by a huge percentage of the American populous) is the true root of the problem. These people are more than willing to dish out millions annually for the construction, staffing, maintenance, and expansion of crime fighting agencies and corrections facilities. This to them seems the appropriate and logical response and use of funds, they are paying for a service that insures their relative safety despite the fact that this very same system has proven to exacerbate poverty, crime, and violence in the long run. Like placing a bandaid over a ruptured artery, these tax payers and politicians alike having nothing but the short term in mind, and it is this outlook that has infected our entire outlook on policy and governance. Ask them to instead allocate an equivalent amount of energy, time, and resources to the education of urban teens and the strengthening of inner city infrastructure and they immediately throw their hands up in protest. To them this strategy is unfair, and those benefitting from it are undeserving or others hand outs. The tax payers would rather have they illusion of their tax dollars being utilized exclusively in their best interest then to fund a productive, community based, restorative project. This classic aggressive stance against perceived socialism or affirmative action has plagued America for its entire existence. So many are convinced that you only deserve what you can pay for, but they never stop to think about the historical and systematic consequences that led to their wealth or others poverty. If we are going to fix this country, we need to start with values and policies by which we appropriate resources and services. An excellent model for this is
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Very thoughtful analyses.
ReplyDeleteAwesome post! I love the emphasis on education as an alternative way of dealing with drugs and "crime". I think that's one of the main reasons the American people have the outlook that Ian talks about --- they believe prisons to be the ONLY way of dealing with drugs and "crime". As Ian showed, this way of dealing with drugs is actually much worse and often exacerbates the issue.
ReplyDeleteAside from education, I think there are a couple other social services that provide similar benefits. Community gardens, better public parks, and drug treatment facilities have all been shown to decrease drug use and crime. As Alexander shows us, some countries (like Portugal) have chosen to address drug abuse as a public health issue rather than a criminal issue. Countries that have adopted this perspective have seen less drug addiction, better success with treatment and recovery, and much less drug-related crime. Oh, and it's cheaper.